The first charge
So far we have taken the hosts as we find them in a working cell. But a cell has a beginning, and the beginning leaves a mark. A lithium-ion cell is assembled discharged, with all its lithium in the positive electrode. On the first charge the graphite is driven down to about 0.2 V vs Li/Li+, below the lower edge of the window in which the carbonate electrolyte is stable (chapter 3). The electrolyte is reduced at the graphite surface, and its products form a passivating layer, the solid-electrolyte interphase or SEI. Forming it consumes lithium from the positive electrode irreversibly, and the layer adds to the interfacial impedance; it also changes as the cell cycles.1
What is reduced, and what does the layer contain? Among the solvents, ethylene carbonate is reduced first, from about 0.8 V vs Li/Li+ (with LiPF6 the anion starts earlier; see Go deeper). Two EC molecules, two lithium ions and two electrons give lithium ethylene dicarbonate (Li2EDC) and ethylene gas; the layer that forms has a dense inorganic inner part next to the graphite (Li2CO3, LiF, Li2O) and a porous organic outer part.2,3
How thick does it get? A crystalline layer only 2 to 3 nm thick would already stop electrons tunnelling through, but on graphite the SEI soon grows past 10 nm and reaches about 50 nm after cycling.2,4
Why the layer helps
We have paid lithium for this layer; let us see what we get back. What makes the SEI useful is its selectivity: it is electronically insulating, so it stops further reduction, yet it conducts Li+, so the graphite keeps filling.5 Of the main solvents, only ethylene carbonate forms a protective layer on graphite, which is why it is in almost every commercial electrolyte; propylene carbonate does not, and as late as 2001 the reason was still described as unclear.6
Why the difference? The explanation usually given, which goes back to Dahn and co-workers in 1990, is that EC decomposes first and builds an SEI that stops PC from slipping into the graphite together with the lithium;7 PC holds on to its Li+ more strongly, goes into the graphite with it, and peels the graphite layers apart.2
By 1994 the picture could be put simply: the layer forms during the first insertion, and after it intercalation is completely reversible.8 In chapter 16 we shall see that this is only nearly true. Conversely, an electrode that works inside the window needs no SEI. Lithium titanate at 1.5 V forms none, and in one report electrodes of lithium titanate and LiFePO4 survived 30 000 cycles at 5C.1
Steering the SEI on purpose
If the layer matters this much, we want to control it. Today the SEI is also steered on purpose, with small amounts of additives that decompose first and leave a thin, controlled layer. The best known is vinylene carbonate (VC): reduced at the graphite above 1 V vs Li/Li+, it forms a passivation layer, and it suppresses the decomposition of PC.9
Why new cells are “formed”. Because the SEI decides how the cell will age, a factory does not leave its growth to chance: near the end of making a cell, it is cycled slowly under precisely defined conditions, for up to a day, and let the gas out before the cell is sealed for good.10 It is expensive, about a third (32 %) of the cost of making a cell, mostly for keeping cells warm while they condition.3 And the first cycle is where the big loss happens: in one recent laboratory cell the first cycle returned about 82.5 % of the charge put in, the second about 97.5 %.3
Not only on graphite. A positive electrode pushed above the upper edge of the window, about 4.3 V, oxidizes the electrolyte instead; LiNi0.5Mn1.5O4 at about 4.75 V is protected by a passivation layer of its own, also called an SEI.1
The SEI costs most of its lithium on the first charge, and then lets the cell work outside its electrolyte’s window.