To compare the two abilities, energy and power, engineers use the Ragone plot. On it, supercapacitors are high-power systems, fuel cells high-energy systems, and batteries sit between them, overlapping both: a battery with thin-film electrodes reaches the power of a supercapacitor.2 No single electrochemical system matches the combustion engine on both axes at once, which is why the review suggests combining them: batteries or supercapacitors for the power, fuel cells for the energy.2
One caution before you trust any Wh/kg figure: the theoretical energy of a chemistry, reckoned on the mass of everything that reacts, is never what a cell delivers. Practical values are significantly lower, and Winter and Brodd list among the causes the inert parts a cell needs (conductive diluents, current collectors, containers), the internal resistances of electrodes, electrolyte and contacts, and incomplete use of the active masses.2
Chapter 2 showed the inert parts; chapter 0 showed why resistance costs voltage, and therefore energy, whenever current flows. How large the gap is depends on the chemistry and on how the cell is built, so this page quotes delivered values only where a source gives them.
To give the numbers a feel, Winter and Brodd note that a specific energy of 30 Wh/kg means one kilogram of lead-acid battery can power a 60 W lamp for only half an hour.2 The first commercial lithium-ion cell of 1991 gave over 3.6 V and 120 to 150 Wh/kg, two to three times the usual nickel-cadmium cell of the day.3
Worked example. Theoretical against delivered, for that 1991 cell: graphite against LiCoO
2, counting all the lithium, so one electron per LiCoO
2 (97.87 g/mol) and one LiC
6 host (72.07 g of carbon) per electron.
active mass per mole of electrons = 97.87 + 72.07 = 169.9 g; Q = 26 801 mAh ÷ 169.9 g = 158 mAh/g
theoretical energy at 3.8 V = 158 mAh/g × 3.8 V ≈ 600 Wh/kg of active material
delivered by the 1991 cell: 120 to 150 Wh/kg, a fifth to a quarter of that
The rest of the mass was copper, aluminium, separator, electrolyte, can and carbon, and part of the lithium in LiCoO
2 was never used.
2–4